A passenger travelled by train a day early for a hospital appointment rather than risk relying on Cambrian services on the day, campaigners have revealed.

The Shrewsbury to Aberystwyth Rail Passengers Association (SARPA) says persistent problems with cancellations, delays and trains running with fewer carriages than expected are undermining confidence in services across mid Wales.

Chair Dr Jeff Smith told the Cambrian News: “SARPA members are very dissatisfied with the persistent reliability problems on the Cambrian Main Line. In recent months we have seen an unacceptable rise in cancellations, delays and short formations.”

He questioned why a shortage of serviceable trains continued to cause disruption when the arrival of new Class 197 units on the Cambrian Coast should have freed up older Class 158 trains for use elsewhere.

The association heard from one passenger who travelled by train and stayed in a hotel overnight before a hospital appointment, rather than risk relying on the service on the day.

He added that while overall passenger numbers on the Cambrian were, according to SARPA, at their highest this century, growth was being driven by leisure journeys, with commuting apparently declining.

“If rail is to provide a sustainable way for people to reach their workplaces, rather than driving, then reliability issues must be urgently addressed,” he said.

The criticism comes weeks after Transport for Wales introduced its new Class 197e trains between Machynlleth and Pwllheli on 19 October, replacing trains that have served the route for more than three decades.

However, the newer fleet has yet to be rolled out across the Aberystwyth to Shrewsbury route. TfW has said further trains will be introduced over the coming months, with Cambrian Coast passengers temporarily required to change at Machynlleth for services towards Shrewsbury and Birmingham.

SARPA says the new coastal services have also suffered delays and shortages.

The group is calling for a dependable hourly service along the Cambrian Main Line, with four carriages on every train between Machynlleth and Shrewsbury.

Dr Smith believes that would encourage passengers back onto the railway, improve access to employment and appointments, and reduce road congestion.

Passengers in southern Meirionnydd face additional difficulties, the association warned, because an early train from Barmouth previously providing a connection at Machynlleth has not been reinstated.

That connection allowed passengers from Barmouth and Tywyn to arrive in Shrewsbury shortly after 9am.

SARPA claims frequent cancellation of the 8.27am Aberystwyth departure now means some passengers cannot reach Shrewsbury until after 11am, with consequences for work, services and leisure travel.

The association wants the early Barmouth service restored alongside wider improvements to reliability.

TfW has previously acknowledged disruption, apologising in July when air-conditioning faults on older Class 158 trains caused cancellations.

On 15 September, TfW confirmed that the 8.27am Aberystwyth to Shrewsbury train had been cancelled because more trains than usual needed repairs, with replacement buses provided.

TfW says its new fleet will improve comfort and accessibility, but SARPA insists reliability must be the priority.

TfW have been contacted for comment regarding the reliability of services on the Cambrian Line.