The devolution of justice has long been discussed in Welsh political circles. With an expanded Senedd, the case for further devolution is stronger than ever, or else we face an oversized Senedd, with more personnel than it knows what to do with.

With the UK Government Secretary of State for Justice Alex Norris hinting at “more to come” on the devolution of justice, particularly youth justice, it’s only right that we start to discuss what a Welsh justice system should look like.

The very first step should be the creation of women’s prison in Wales. We currently don’t have one, and previous plans for one have fallen through.

Lloyd Warburton
Lloyd Warburton (Lloyd Warburton)

Every prisoner should be housed in their country of residence, and that means that no prisoners from elsewhere should be housed in Wales, and those who committed crimes in Wales should be incarcerated here, regardless of sex, age or the offence.

I would like to see a radical overhaul of sentencing guidelines, with automatic lengthy custodial sentences for those caught in possession of indecent images of children, and a massive increase in prison terms for driving offences which result in death to innocent people. Some sentences we see reported for dangerous driving deaths are frankly insulting.

We also need to review the need for non-violent criminals who pose no physical threat to the public to be behind bars.

So called ‘white-collar’ crimes like fraud and embezzlement, for example. They are undeniably awful crimes with real victims and implications, but should perpetrators really be imprisoned ahead of paedophiles or violent criminals?

In an ideal world, all should be jailed, but it isn’t one, and whilst prisons across the UK are overcrowded, there needs to be emphasis on protecting the public from violence, and victims from dangerous offenders.

House arrest and asset seizure should be the norm for white-collar crimes in a strained system.

Drug offences are another key issue.

I have always been relatively conservative on drugs. I have seen the impact they have, and would support any and all efforts to eliminate the most dangerous substances from society.

But organised crime network are smart.

In a Welsh justice system, those simply caught in possession of drugs for personal use should not be criminalised.

They should be offered maximum support to move away from addiction and always have the opportunity to build a clean, productive life. Approaching drug addiction any differently to alcoholism or problem gambling is an arbitrary double-standard.

Dealers and producers should instead face the full force of the law. The ‘County Lines’ network needs to be liquidated, and those involved should face extreme sentences, and any resources saved by not prosecuting drug users should be diverted to destroying the supply networks.

The biggest opportunity in devolving justice would come in what we could do to youth justice. We could raise the age of criminal responsibility from 10 to, say, 13, and make the process more friendly to young people, encourage responsibility and reconciliation over punishment for less serious crimes, and try new ways of breaking the cycle of offending as early as possible.

Devolving justice would provide an incredible opportunity for Wales to build a better system for the Welsh people, but the Welsh Government will need to use these powers effectively.

We can’t just keep forming commissions and hoping for the best!