Halloween night, I took my son trick-or-treating in Borth. Lower Borth is built on a shingle ridge, making the village essentially a single mile-long street. This layout is perfect for trick-or-treating: a mile up the High Street, a mile back, and a half-mile circular on the cliff. Between six and seven pm, children coalesce into a sugar-high horde. Many locals dress up, and despite global economic conditions, this year’s harvest was spectacular.

My son attends the local primary school, which two years ago was threatened with closure alongside three others in Ceredigion. Consequently, walking the High Street means bumping into parents, grandparents, and relatives; the entire school community is out. We are all so different—Welsh, English, and non-British backgrounds, different first languages, jobs, and interests.

Before moving to Borth, my son spent his reception year in an inner-city school in York, with 400 pupils. It was a terrific school, well-resourced, and the head still took care to know every child and parent by name. But on the school grounds, parents clustered in their own cells, often along class lines. In Wales, first language often adds another layer of division.

GUEST COLUMN
Rev Prof Jasper Kenter 
letters@cambrian-news.co.uk
GUEST COLUMN Rev Prof Jasper Kenter [email protected] (GUEST COLUMN Rev Prof Jasper Kenter [email protected])

Village schools are unique in bridging these gaps. They are central to the village fabric and bring children of different backgrounds together for the rest of their lives.

In Ceredigion, the four previously threatened schools will remain open. Notwithstanding unfounded rumours, they now again have the same status as any other schools in the county.

However, the pressures haven’t changed. Pupil numbers are declining due to fewer young people, meaning smaller classes that cost more per pupil. Demographic trends are a triple hit on councils: fewer children, fewer working-age people (shrinking the council tax base), and more elderly people (increasing social care costs).

These factors, alongside inflation, explain recent council tax hikes. Education and social care account for 60% of Welsh local authorities’ costs. While this newspaper rightly calls out poor management, it is not an enviable job managing these pressures.

In Ceredigion, the Plaid-led cabinet that proposed closing the schools blamed the former Labour Welsh Government for a funding formula that was not sustainable for local schools. In Carmarthenshire, a Plaid-Independent Cabinet recently voted to close two schools, Ysgol Meidrim and Ysgol y Fro, which were originally put up for closure by the previous Plaid-Labour Cabinet. The current Cabinet has voted further to consult on closing four more schools.

Some of these schools have very low pupil numbers (for example, only 14 for Ysgol y Fro and 8 for Ysgol Meidrim). Yet it is hard to avoid the impression of a lack of overall vision on what kind of education we want in rural Wales. On the one hand, there is the Welsh Government’s platform of safeguarding small rural schools, and on the other hand, there are visions of ‘modernisation’ and ‘consolidation’ projected by local authorities. Both Plaid and Labour seem continually split on the issue, with national Plaid politicians lobbying their own local cabinet colleagues against closure and councillors regularly voting against Cabinet members in their own party.

Closures generally appear reactive – councils need to cut budget and salami-slice school provision with an arbitrary number of small schools here and there, to make relatively small savings, after increased school transport costs are accounted for. It is difficult in this context for any small school to feel secure, because there is always a feeling of ‘who is next’. This in itself undermines rural schools.

In contrast, in Scotland there is a much clearer shared vision that village schools should be safeguarded to the sustain rural communities, plus a strong policy framework to support this. This includes, for example, a dedicated funding stream, recruitment incentives for staff, and stronger adaptations to the inspection framework than in Wales to recognise the specific challenges of village schools, such as multi-age teaching. There is also a community right to bid to retain schools themselves.

Such policies could benefit Wales, but at least as important is that local authorities actively support schools to make the most of their potential. In villages like Borth, a community of around a thousand people, the problem is not an absolute lack of children, but the absence of a cylch meithrin or nursery and only limited wraparound care in the school. This means many working parents enrol their children in schools elsewhere with more childcare. An effective Welsh policy framework for local schools thus has to integrate primary education with early years provision.

At the local level, salami slicing of rural education has to stop. Politicians should decide what they want. Is it consolidation and larger schools? Then sell a clear and honest story of what that means overall. Is it protection of village schools? Then work actively and continuously with communities to make village schools successful and overcome whatever local barriers there are to enrolment, rather than passively leaving the distribution of pupils across schools to the market.

Large, polished, well-resourced schools like the one my son attended in York can seem appealing compared to the tiny but intimate schools with only two or three members of staff and a few handfuls of children. But closing local schools comes at a real cost to communities that is difficult to undo once schools are closed. They support a deep sense of belonging to community and place, a sense of cynefin. Village schools are often anchors in the landscape, have deep historical connotations, act as community hubs, intergeneration bridges and centres of cultural and linguistic identity. They bring people together, no matter who they are.

This is invaluable and can’t be expressed in money. Though in Borth, on Halloween night, it is expressed in grams of sugar…

The author is Professorial Research Fellow at Aberystwyth Business School and a One Spirit Interfaith Minister.